1 comments

  • zeusdclxvi 5 hours ago
    The polybolos was an advanced ancient Greek repeating ballista, often described as a "machine gun of antiquity," invented in the 3rd century BC by Dionysius of Alexandria. It used a unique chain-drive and gravity-fed system to fire bolts in rapid succession
    • mkl 3 hours ago
      https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polybolos

      Apparently it was on MythBusters, but I don't remember that one.

    • zadikian 2 hours ago
      I've heard of this, but what's the advantage? They still need to recharge the torsion the same way, which must've taken longer than someone manually feeding the next bolt.
      • bfivyvysj 2 hours ago
        You can't imagine why a quick succession of bolt fire might be more advantageous than a slow reload?
        • zadikian 2 hours ago
          I mean how is it actually faster if the rate limiting step is the same. People are claiming it was 2-3X as fast.
          • Someone 56 minutes ago
            Reading https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polybolos, at least some of these used a windlass to rearm. That may explain part of the speed difference over one using a separate lever or one that’s rearmed purely by hand.

            These weapons also may have given up on some firing power for firing frequency.

          • eucyclos 2 hours ago
            Maybe it's harder to deal with ten projectiles in a minute followed by a nine minute reload than one a minute for ten minutes?
            • zadikian 2 hours ago
              I'm not even considering the magazine reload time, just the time between shots assuming a full mag. That's 10 recharges either way, as shown in the videos. It's not like a machine gun where the energy is in the powder.
            • ithkuil 2 hours ago
              Even a short surprise can be crucial in an ancient battle, where breaking formation can be fatal
      • normie3000 2 hours ago
        Maybe one less operator required? Less chance of losing a hand?
        • zadikian 2 hours ago
          Yeah I figured it's more convenient, but they're claiming it's also twice as fast.

          With the chu ko nu I get it, you only have two hands, so the auto reload was faster.

      • adzm 1 hour ago
        The psychological advantage can't be discounted either