Show HN: Remote-Controlled IKEA Deathstar Lamp

(gitlab.com)

223 points | by sephalon 12 hours ago

10 comments

  • larusso 10 hours ago
    Cool project indeed. I used to own the first model and thought about how one could motorize the lamp. I used to own the one which didn’t have the reflected coating on the inside panels. At least in Germany they changed that a few years back from plain white to silver or gold reflection. And now the lamp is also available in bigger sizes. I bought it like most because of the interesting design. But was never really pleased with it. Practical use of keeping it closed is zero. I guess that was the reason to motorize it ;) But even in the open configuration it’s so dark that it’s unusable as a promised light source.
    • sephalon 1 hour ago
      Part of the reason for automating it was that I wanted to integrate the lamp into my home theater setup: When the movie starts, the lamp slowly closes and synchronously dims out (guests always react with a smile to this). Pressing the pause button dims it up again and gives one just enough light to find the bathroom ;-)
    • t0mas88 9 hours ago
      I have the one with copper inside coating, it works well as a lamp above the dining table with an 800 lumen LED lamp in it. I usually don't even have it set to the highest brightness.
      • larusso 5 hours ago
        Maybe the coated ones do work better. For my use the lamp was simply not bright enough.
    • eastbound 7 hours ago
      Oh, no: the practical reason to keep it closed is when you switch it on at night, it shouldn’t suddenly brighten up the room at max volume, but open up progressively so your eyes can accomodate.

      Of course if you live with someone, you don’t switch on the lights at night ;)

    • throw94944848 5 hours ago
      [flagged]
  • hnlmorg 5 hours ago
    I owned one of these lights before it went viral and it was a nightmare to install. The thing doesn’t screw into the ceiling like every other light figure does. Instead you install a hook and dangle the damn thing off the hook. Which means the plastic surround never goes flush with the ceiling.

    Even when you do finally get it flush after several painful iterations of hanging it, gravity stretches the cord causing the base to come slightly away from the ceiling again.

    If you’re OCD like me, it made the light a horrible reminder of that OCD. So in the end I gave up on the light.

    Pity because it’s a really cool looking light.

    • Ambroos 3 minutes ago
      I wonder if this is a Swedish thing. I recently moved to a newly built apartment in Stockholm (as a non-Swede). All spots to put a ceiling light come with a hook and DCL socket, so it makes it super easy to swap lamps.
    • nemetroid 5 hours ago
      Never seen a light fixture that screws into the ceiling.
      • EvanAnderson 5 hours ago
        Some fixtures screw into an electrical box attached to the studs in the ceiling. The IKEA SIMRISHAMN pendant does that, for example.
        • nemetroid 4 hours ago
          Looking at the Ikea US website, the Simrishamn and PS 2014 seem to have similar solutions: a plate that screws into an electrical box and provides a hook (the lowest common international denominator).

          What do you do if you want to move a ceiling light a bit to the side? Do you install an entire new electrical box?

          • hnlmorg 4 hours ago
            If those electrical boxes are anything like the ones in the video I shared, then they’re trivial to move.

            You don’t actually need the box though. In fact they weren’t even available in my previous two homes. It’s really more a convenience thing than anything.

            But again, this is assuming we are talking about the same thing (region differences and all).

            • linsomniac 4 hours ago
              In the US, NEC and most local codes (which are often based on some version of the NEC) require that connections be made inside a box. This is largely because connections are the most likely place for an electrical fire to start and the box helps contain it.
      • hnlmorg 4 hours ago
        I can’t speak for where you are, but it’s the norm in the uk. Eg around 4:25 in this video https://youtu.be/WZizlnLfLks?si=LjRI1EWIHhn6Ktgx

        When I bought the Ikea light, it was just hook and no way to fix the plastic surround to the ceiling.

        Ikea might have updated the light since then though. As I said before, I got the light when it was new, long before it went viral, and ikea might have tweaked the design since.

  • badmonster 1 hour ago
    Can the Deathstar lamp firmware be customized to add new modes, like an automatic opening and closing cycle synced to music or other triggers?
  • keyle 7 hours ago
    Just in time for May 4th. Well done!
  • bitwize 2 hours ago
    This lamp made a big splash among game designer Tetsuya Mizuguchi and his friends/fans a few years back, because it resembles the first boss of Rez (on which Mizuguchi was the lead): https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=tStDX7QHNwI

    When I saw this story I didn't recognize the model number and I thought "Hey, is that the Rez lamp?" sure enough...

  • jansan 9 hours ago
    What a gem of a project. I am a huge fan of the PS 2014. To me it is one of the best IKEA products ever, even better than the discontiued Broder shelf system. We bought the large version with copper reflector for my son's room almost ten years ago and until today the mechanism works and it just looks great (it "ties the room together" for those who know). My idea was to replace the balls on the strings with little iron cast x-wings from a key chain ring, but they would always fly into the wrong direction, because the connector is at the back of the x-wing. I do not want some x-wings constantly flying cowardly away from our death star.

    This project looks awesome and I will give it a shot, because it actually looks doable for a first ESP32 project. But I will first try it on the smaller version of the PS 2014 before I start working on my son's lamp.

    • progbits 8 hours ago
      When expanded and illuminated red from within it looks like it's exploding, so you can think of it as xwings retreating to safe distance after successful bombing run :)
  • kqr 8 hours ago
    Why does this lamp make people think of the death star? Me and my wife bought it ten years ago because of the cool mechanism and immediately started calling it the death star, but I struggle to see what the resemblance really is.
    • enlyth 8 hours ago
      Because it.. kind of looks like the death star?
    • croes 1 hour ago
      I think it’s the angular shapes on a globe that triggers that.

      https://starcorridors.github.io/src/img/death-star.png

    • jansan 4 hours ago
      Three simple reasons:

      - It's spherical

      - The pattern of the tiles slightly resembles the pattern on the death star

      - When you open it, it looks like it "explodes", like every proper death star eventually does

    • saaaaaam 8 hours ago
      I find your comment very confusing! You don’t understand why people call it the Death Star but as soon as you got the lamp you started calling it the Death Star but you struggle to see the resemblance? Surely you’ve answered your own question…?!
      • kqr 8 hours ago
        No. This is a case where I am confused by my own behaviour as well! Clearly there is something about it but it's not something I'm conscious about.
        • danielbln 8 hours ago
          I always called it DustStar because God damn does it collect dust.
        • tekla 7 hours ago
          Because it looks like the Death Star.
      • croes 1 hour ago
        The question is why all see the same and not just OP
  • throw94944848 5 hours ago
    [flagged]
  • rurban 7 hours ago
    [flagged]
  • timzaman 11 hours ago
    Didn't know anyone still used gitlab. Also video not working..
    • sephalon 10 hours ago
      Thanks for letting me know about the video playback issue, I used the following script to create the timelapse:

        ffmpeg \
         -pattern_type glob \
         -framerate 30 \
         -i "img/*.JPG" \
         -i "star_wars_style_march.mp3" \
         -s:v 1920x1080 \
         -c:a libopus \
         -c:v vp9 \
         -shortest \
         deathstar_timelapse.webm
      
      I actually thought that VP9 and Opus are well supported everywhere by now, but maybe that is not the case…

      Regarding GitLab, as a general rule, I try to avoid products dominating the market, and I quite like their OSS policy…

      • sephalon 7 hours ago
        I have converted the timelapse to H.264/AAC, hope this plays everywhere now.
      • stuaxo 7 hours ago
        Android Firefox says it won't play because it's corrupted.
      • watermelon0 8 hours ago
        VP9/WEBM should be supported by all modern browsers: https://caniuse.com/webm
      • rcarmo 10 hours ago
        You should have used mp4. Not all browsers support vp9.
    • ramon156 10 hours ago
      > Didn't know anyone still used gitlab

      Why wouldn't someone use gitlab

      • nicce 9 hours ago
        For self-hosting, there are non-profits available, and in commercial world pricing got out of hand when comparing features. GitHub dominates too much.
    • mimischi 11 hours ago
      The embedded video in the README is working just fine in Safari on iOS
      • thenthenthen 10 hours ago
        Safari iOS not working here either
      • kjrrp 8 hours ago
        Doesn't work in Firefox for Android ("file is corrupt").
      • DidYaWipe 10 hours ago
        Doesn't work in desktop Safari either.
      • wbnns 10 hours ago
        Doesn't seem to work in Brave
        • esperent 9 hours ago
          I'm using Brave on Android, works fine. Maybe the author updated it?
      • solosito 11 hours ago
        Not for me
    • stavros 10 hours ago
      • razemio 10 hours ago
        iOS (all the sma browsers / safari) it does not load. Download is jot an issue.
      • DidYaWipe 10 hours ago
        Plays in VLC if you download it.
    • shrx 10 hours ago
      Works in Waterfox.
    • elkos 10 hours ago
      Why so?